Association of Mexican-American Educators; California Association for Asian-Pacific Bilingual Education, on behalf of themselves, their members, and all others similarly situated; Oakland Alliance of Black Educators, on behalf of themselves, their members, and all others similarly situated; Sara MacNeil Boyd; Sam Genis; Toua Yang; Bob Williams; Marta Leclaire; Antoinette Williams; Diana Kwan and Agnes Haynes, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Cross-Appellees, v California; the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing, Defendants-Appellees-Cross-Appellants

195 F3d 465

United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit

United States

28th October, 1999

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text	Citation Index
Association of Mexican-American Educators ("Amae"); California Association for Asian-Pacific Bilingual Education ("Cafabe"), on behalf of themselves, their members, and all others similarly situated; Oakland Alliance of Black Educators ("Oabe"), on behalf of themselves, their members, and all others similarly situated; Sara MacNeil Boyd;Sam Genis; Toua Yang; Bob Williams; Marta Leclaire; Antoinette Williams; Diana Kwan; and Agnes Haynes, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs-Appellants/ Cross-Appellees, v California; the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing, Defendants-Appellees/ Cross-Appellants		United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	30 Oct 2000	WorldLII
Association of Mexican-American Educators; California Association for Asian-Pacific Bilingual Education, on behalf of themselves, their members, and all others similarly situated; Oakland Alliance of Black Educators, on behalf of themselves, their members, and all others similarly situated; Sara MacNeil Boyd; Sam Genis; Toua Yang; Bob Williams; Marta Leclaire; Antoinette Williams; Diana Kwan and Agnes Haynes, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs-Appellants-Cross-Appellees, v California; the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing, Defendants-Appellees-Cross-Appellants		United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	28 Oct 1999	WorldLII

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name	Provision
Constitution

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text	Citation Index
Davis v Monroe County Bd of Educ	526 US 629; 143 L Ed 2d 839; 119 SCt 1661	United States Supreme Court	United States	24 May 1999	WorldLII	73
United States of America, Ex Rel , Margaret A Newsham v Lockheed Missiles & Space Co	171 F3d 1208	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	24 Mar 1999	WorldLII	4
Burrey	159 F3d 388	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	20 Oct 1998	WorldLII	10
Ferguson v City of Phoenix	157 F3d 668	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	8 Oct 1998	WorldLII	10
National Collegiate Athletic Assn v Smith	139 F3d 180; 119 SCt 924; 142 L Ed 2d 929	United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit	United States	16 Mar 1998	WorldLII	22
United States Norton Sound Health Corporation v Bering Strait School District	138 F3d 1281; 125 Ed Law Rep 22	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	12 Mar 1998	WorldLII	3
Newark Branch National Association for the Advancement of Colored People v City of Bayonne New Jersey	134 F3d 113	United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit	United States	13 Jan 1998	WorldLII	5
Lightbourn	118 F3d 421; 38 Fed RServ3d 10	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	1 Aug 1997	WorldLII	12
United States v City of Yonkers	96 F3d 600; 112 Ed Law Rep 601	United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit	United States	23 Sep 1996	WorldLII	7
Melendez v Illinois Bell Tel Co	79 F3d 661	United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit	United States	27 Mar 1996	WorldLII	20
National Information Services Inc v Trw Inc National Information Services Inc Cdb	51 F3d 1470	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	30 Jun 1995	WorldLII	19
Export Group v Reef Indus , Inc	54 F3d 1466	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	22 May 1995	WorldLII	48
Virgo v Riviera Beach Assocs , Ltd	30 F3d 1350	United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit	United States	1 Sep 1994	WorldLII	29
Beard v Teska	31 F3d 942; 93 Ed Law Rep 530	United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit	United States	26 Jul 1994	WorldLII	23
Farrar v Hobby	506 US 103; 121 L Ed 2d 494; 113 SCt 566	United States Supreme Court	United States	14 Dec 1992	WorldLII	405
Jl Kp v Social Security Administration S D Md	971 F2d 260	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	15 Jul 1992	WorldLII	7
Belanger v Madera Unified School District	963 F2d 248; 75 Ed Law Rep 118; 58 Empl Prac Dec P 41,437	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	29 Apr 1992	WorldLII	23
Schroeder v City of Chicago	927 F2d 957	United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit	United States	13 Mar 1991	WorldLII	21
Smith v Barton	914 F2d 1330; 59 USLW 2205; 54 Empl Prac Dec P 40,264; 53 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1552	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	19 Sep 1990	WorldLII	40
Fields v Hallsville Independent School District	906 F2d 1017; 61 Ed Law Rep 442; 54 Empl Prac Dec P 40,122; 53 Fair Empl Prac Cas 877	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	30 Jul 1990	WorldLII	14
Spencer v General Electric Co E Spencer	894 F2d 651; 52 Empl Prac Dec P 39,583; 15 Fed RServ3d 1091; 51 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1725; 58 USLW 2506	United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit	United States	13 Feb 1990	WorldLII	23
Bernard v Gulf Oil Corporation	890 F2d 735; 15 Fed RServ3d 556; 52 Empl Prac Dec P 39,531; 51 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1126	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	18 Dec 1989	WorldLII	5
Morgan v Safeway Stores Inc	884 F2d 1211; 51 Empl Prac Dec P 39,314; 58 USLW 2210; 50 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1339	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	6 Sep 1989	WorldLII	2
Reilly v United States	863 F2d 149; 27 Fed REvid Serv 90	United States Court of Appeals, First Circuit	United States	14 Dec 1988	WorldLII	49
Baker v McNeil Island Corrections Center	859 F2d 124; 57 USLW 2257; 47 Empl Prac Dec P 38,360; 48 Fair Empl Prac Cas 143	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	12 Oct 1988	WorldLII	26
Cleghorn v S Herrington E E	813 F2d 992; 42 Empl Prac Dec P 36,957; 43 Fair Empl Prac Cas 613	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	27 Mar 1987	WorldLII	10
MacDonald, Sommer & Frates v Yolo County	477 US 340; 91 L Ed 2d 285; 106 SCt 2561	United States Supreme Court	United States	3 Sep 1986	WorldLII	98
Larry Lucille P v Riles P	793 F2d 969	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	25 Jun 1986	WorldLII	15
George v New Jersey Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners W	794 F2d 113; 41 Empl Prac Dec P 36,551; 43 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1380	United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit	United States	5 Jun 1986	WorldLII	5
Haddock v Board of Dental Examiners of California	777 F2d 462; 38 Empl Prac Dec P 35,777; 39 Fair Empl Prac Cas 764	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	26 Nov 1985	WorldLII	18
Clady v County of Los Angeles	770 F2d 1421; 38 Empl Prac Dec P 35,516; 38 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1575	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	13 Nov 1985	WorldLII	33
Wrighten v Metropolitan Hospitals Inc	726 F2d 1346; 33 Empl Prac Dec P 34,137; 33 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1714	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	29 Feb 1984	WorldLII	47
Los Angeles Branch Naacp Naacp Naacp Naacp Naacp Naacp v Los Angeles Unified School District	714 F2d 946; 13 Ed Law Rep 45	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	1 Sep 1983	WorldLII	14
Moore v Hughes Helicopters, Inc	708 F2d 475; 32 Empl Prac Dec P 33,688; 32 Fair Empl Prac Cas 97	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	16 Jun 1983	WorldLII	50
Gomez v Alexian Brothers Hospital of San Jose	698 F2d 1019; 31 Empl Prac Dec P 33,328; 30 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1705	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	9 Feb 1983	WorldLII	12
Delta Air Lines Inc v Colbert	692 F2d 489; 30 Empl Prac Dec P 33,152; 32 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1757	United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit	United States	5 Nov 1982	WorldLII	11
National Organization for Women v Bank of California National Association	680 F2d 1291; 29 Empl Prac Dec P 32,937; 29 Fair Empl Prac Cas 300	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	8 Jul 1982	WorldLII	15
United States v McConney	728 F2d 1195	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	15 Jun 1982	WorldLII	978
Contreras v City of Los Angeles	656 F2d 1267; 27 Empl Prac Dec P 32,182; 29 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1045	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	14 Sep 1981	WorldLII	37
Watson v Gulf and Western Industries	650 F2d 990; 26 Empl Prac Dec P 31,977; 26 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1180	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	23 Jun 1981	WorldLII	12
Idaho Migrant Council v Board of Education	647 F2d 69	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	5 Jun 1981	WorldLII	7
Pennhurst State School and Hospital v Halderman	451 US 1; 67 L Ed 2d 694; 101 SCt 1531; 320 USApp DC 215	United States Supreme Court	United States - District of Columbia	20 Apr 1981	WorldLII	342
Owens v F Rush	636 F2d 283; 24 Empl Prac Dec P 31,401; 24 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1563	United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit	United States	15 Dec 1980	WorldLII	21
Lutcher v Musicians Union Local 47	633 F2d 880; 24 Empl Prac Dec P 31,402; 24 Fair Empl Prac Cas 859	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	8 Dec 1980	WorldLII	28
Craig v County of Los Angeles	626 F2d 659; 24 Empl Prac Dec P 31,297; 24 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1105	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	22 Sep 1980	WorldLII	20
Guardians Association of New York City Police Department Inc v Civil Service Commission of City of New York	630 F2d 79; 23 Empl Prac Dec P 31,154; 23 Fair Empl Prac Cas 909	United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit	United States	31 Jul 1980	WorldLII	35
Guardians Association of the New York City Police Department, Inc v Civil Service Commission of City of New York	633 F2d 232; 6 Fed REvid Serv 724; 23 Empl Prac Dec P 31,153; 23 Fair Empl Prac Cas 677	United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit	United States	25 Jul 1980	WorldLII	31
Reeves, Inc v Stake	447 US 429; 65 L Ed 2d 244; 100 SCt 2271	United States Supreme Court	United States	19 Jun 1980	WorldLII	72
Ensley Branch of v Seibels W Martin	616 F2d 812; 23 Empl Prac Dec P 30,924; 22 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1207	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	16 Jun 1980	WorldLII	12
Quijano v University Federal Credit Union	617 F2d 129; 23 Empl Prac Dec P 30,933; 22 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1307	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	15 May 1980	WorldLII	11
Woodard v Virginia Board of Bar Examiners W III	598 F2d 1345; 29 Fair Empl Prac Cas 841	United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit	United States	24 May 1979	WorldLII	13
Cannon v University of Chicago	441 US 677; 60 L Ed 2d 560; 99 SCt 1946	United States Supreme Court	United States	14 May 1979	WorldLII	528
Blake v City of Los Angeles	595 F2d 1367; 53 ALRFed 1; 19 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1441	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	2 May 1979	WorldLII	33
[1979] Idaho 18	[1979] Idaho 18		United States - Idaho	circa 1979		1
Baker v Stuart Broadcasting Co	560 F2d 389; 49 ALRFed 894; 15 Fair Empl Prac Cas 394	United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit	United States	11 Aug 1977	WorldLII	31
Dothard v Rawlinson	433 US 321; 53 L Ed 2d 786; 97 SCt 2720; [1977] Moore 708; [1977] Kirby 613	United States Supreme Court	United States	27 Jun 1977	WorldLII	279
Dothard v Rawlinson Hazelwood School District	97 SCt 2748	United States Supreme Court	United States	27 Jun 1977	WorldLII	72
United States v City of Chicago	549 F2d 415; 13 Empl Prac Dec P 11,380; 40 ALRFed 421; 14 Fair Empl Prac Cas 462	United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit	United States	11 Jan 1977	WorldLII	55
Kirkland v New York State Department of Correctional Services M L	520 F2d 420; 10 Empl Prac Dec P 10,357; 11 Fair Empl Prac Cas 38	United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit	United States	6 Aug 1975	WorldLII	35
Albemarle Paper Co v Moody	422 US 405; 45 L Ed 2d 280; 95 SCt 2362; (1975) 43 USLW 4880	United States Supreme Court	United States	25 Jun 1975	WorldLII	837
Popeil Brothers Inc v Schick Electric Inc	516 F2d 772; 186 USPQ 244	United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit	United States	6 May 1975	WorldLII	31
Griggs v Duke Power Co	401 US 424; 28 L Ed 2d 158; 91 SCt 849	United States Supreme Court	United States	8 Mar 1971	WorldLII	970
JL v Social Sec Admin	971 F2d 270		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	2
937 FSupp 1412-16	937 FSupp 1412-16		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	2
Association of Mexican-American Educators v California	937 FSupp 1397		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	3
VI Grimes v Superior Home Health Care	929 FSupp 1088		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	2
Upper Valley Ass'n for Handicapped Citizens v Mills	928 FSupp 429		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	2
Butt v California	842 P2d 1240		United States	circa 1980		3
Association of Mexican-American Educators v California	836 FSupp 1543		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	2
Association of Mexican American Educators v California	836 FSupp 1534		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	3
State v Project Principle, Inc	724 SW 2d 387	US		circa 1980		4
United States v City of Yonkers	592 FSupp 570		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	2
Steel Co v Citizens for a Better Env't	523 US 83; 118 SCt 1003; 140 L Ed 2d 210	United States Supreme Court	United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	662
Rivas v State Bd for Community Colleges	517 FSupp 467		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	3
Sibley Memorial Hospital v Wilson	488 F2d 1338; 160 USApp DC 14		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	44
Vanguard Justice Society, Inc v Hughes	471 FSupp 670		United States		Westlaw	6
Curran v Portland Superintending School Committee	435 FSupp 1063		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	12
Puntolillo v New Hampshire Racing Commission	375 FSupp 1089		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	10
Woods v Interstate Realty Co	337 US 535	United States Supreme Court	United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	140
Pursche v Atlas Scraper & Eng'g Co	300 F2d 467		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	39
Johnson v San Diego Unified Sch Dist	266 Cal Rptr 187; 217 Cal App3d 692		United States - California	circa 1980		3
195 f3d 465			United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	2
Stanley v University of Southern California	178 F3d 1069		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	9
118 SCt 512	118 SCt 512		United States	circa 1980	Westlaw	193
Kennedy v Miller	97 Cal 429		United States - California	circa 1980		2
Bagdai v Nazar	84 F3d 1194		United States		Westlaw	290
Hall v City of Taft	47 Cal2d 177; 302 P2d 574		United States - California	circa 1980		7
Hartzell v Connell	35 Cal3d 899		United States - California			2
Kennedy v Miller	32 P 558					2
Agcaoili and Associates	6 P 2					24
San Francisco Unified School District v Johnson	3 Cal3d 937; 479 P2d 669; 92 Cal Rptr 309		United States - California	circa 1980		6
Gonzales v California			United States - California	circa 1980
Choice-In-Education League v Los Angeles Unified Sch Dist			United States - California	circa 1980
California Teachers Ass'n v Board of Trustees			United States - California	circa 1980
First Interstate Bank of California v California			United States - California	circa 1980

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback